An operation and maintenance manual can move through several review cycles before the client accepts it. A review register should preserve what was requested, who responded and which revision addresses the comment. A colour-coded list of filenames alone cannot explain that history.

Break review into identifiable items

Agree a stable comment number and retain it across revisions. Capture the manual identifier, system or asset, section/page reference, reviewer, comment date, requested action, responsible responder, response, revised-file link and resolution status. Use the project’s agreed status labels and keep their definitions beside the register.

Separate a missing section from a technical question. For example, “equipment schedule not located” concerns the supplied content, while “maintenance interval requires designer confirmation” needs a technical owner. The coordinator can route both issues but should not supply an engineering answer to close the row.

Use one coordinated response

In a hypothetical mechanical package, the client returns Revision B with twelve comments. The supplier answers by email, the installer changes an asset schedule and the designer clarifies an operating description. Consolidate those contributions against the twelve original comment numbers. Record the source and approver for each response rather than presenting a blended answer as the coordinator’s own technical judgement.

When Revision C arrives, link it to the response register and check that every claimed change can be located. This is a navigation check. Whether the response is satisfactory remains the reviewer’s decision.

Avoid premature closure

Use “response supplied—review pending” when the author has answered but the reviewer has not accepted it. If a comment is withdrawn, retain the reason and the authority for withdrawal. Do not change its status to closed merely to improve a dashboard total.

Keep an index of the current manual and superseded issues, with the formal submission or transmittal reference. Ensure the final pack points to the accepted version while retaining review history according to the project’s document-control arrangements.

Queensland building handover guidance describes the role of manuals and other supporting documents in handover. The client’s contract and deliverable schedule determine the actual manual contents and approval process. A review register supports that process by making decisions traceable; it cannot replace the appointed reviewer or convert incomplete technical content into an approved manual.